TotalBiscuit, a YouTube gaming critic, is one of the most popular âpersonalitiesâ on the service. When he says a game is rubbish, people notice. And when the company behind that game tries to get his criticism taken offline, more people notice.
Earlier this month, he posted a look at a game called Day One: Garryâs Incident. Claiming (and supporting with apparent screengrabs) that heâd been sent the game by its developers specifically for review, he called it, among other things, âhorrendousâ.
Over this past weekend, Wild Games Studio issued a takedown notice to TotalBiscuit forcing the removal of his critique, their CEO âStephaneâ posting on the Steam forums that âWe protected our copyright because Total Biscuit has no right to make advertising revenues with our license.â
Note that other videos of the game â some even containing equally negative commentary â were never removed from YouTube, nor was our own video look at the game. Understandable, since âStephaneâ had previously given the companyâs blessing to people making YouTube videos of their game.
A Reddit post later collected his comments that his YouTube channel providers will be pursuing the matter legally on Monday, and summed up his side of the story with âLong story short. Dev sends code, code used to make critique, dev dislikes critique, dev abuses system to censor critique.â
They might not bother now. We contacted Wild Games for comment, and were told by âStephaneâ that, âafter seeing all the negative impact today we decided to withdraw our complaint to YouTube.â
UPDATE, 10/21. Developer apologizes; video back up
