Borderlands 2: The Kotaku Review

Now Borderlands is back, sporting the same cel-shaded style and boasting even more loot and even more enemies. Gearbox practically invented a new number (it’s in the bazillions) just to account for all the guns you can find on the planet Pandora. Fire-pistols, corrosive-SMGs, slag (a smokey purple effect) shotguns, shocking-sniper rifles. You use whatever your trigger-happy heart desires against enemies big and midget. Some of said enemies attack you with their own elemental effects. A muscular goliath will vomit up corrosive acid on you. Or a spiderant will attack with slag. Feisty robots will burn you with flamethrowers. The combinations are wild. And damn dangerous.

WHY: Borderlands 2 is a charming, funny, hell of a cooperative game with lots of style and personality that you can spend hours with.

Borderlands 2

Developer: Gearbox

Platforms: Xbox 360 (Played), PlayStation 3, PC

Releases: September 18

Type of game: First-person shooter/RPG hybrid

What I played: 50ish hours to finish the main campaign, and a large chunk of side quests, as well as some dabbling in New Game +.

My Two Favorite Things

So many powerful guns to shoot so many creative enemies.

Charming, funny personality in everything from the names of quests and NPCs to the actual dialogue. And the story is much better this time around.

My Two Least-Favorite Things

Getting snagged on invisible and visible corners. There are a lot of things you can bump into.

Borderlands 2 is too encouraging of a cooperative experience by its difficulty. Especially considering how tough enemies are, but how little ammunition you are supplied with.

Made-to-Order-Back-of-Box-Quotes

“I need more friends. So I can play more Borderlands 2. This is important. Please and thank you.” —Tina Amini, Kotaku.com

“I’m saddened that fireball-throwing pistols are not a real thing that I can have. I’d keep it under my pillow and sing it lullabies.”—Tina Amini, Kotaku.com

I laughed a lot in Borderlands 1. I giggled at the names of bosses and my eyes sparkled at shiny new weapons. I enjoyed listening to dialogue from all the personalities of non-player characters, showing off their paranoia or charismatic banter.

But my heart never dropped in Borderlands 1. I was never shocked or appalled by something I just witnessed in the progression of the story. I felt all those things on my second run through Pandora. It caught me completely off guard in the best way, even if I’m still upset by the things that happened. The story in Borderlands 2 occasionally gets serious, dark even, and it was something I felt and believed rather than just listened to. I have never been so invested in Pandora and its citizens until this sequel.

Some decisions about combat confused me, though. While pursuing certain quest lines imperative to the main story, you’ll begin a long sequence through the one zone it’s contained in. These range from snowy battlegrounds filled with mechs to bandit camps filled with tattooed psychos. These treks last for awhile. Typically they’ll start off with a health and ammo vending machine so you can load up before you run into enemies.

But Borderlands 2 is a difficult game with fickle enemies. They’re hell-bent on living. One ammo vendor just won’t cut it, especially when enemies tend to drop more money than they do ammunition. And if you’re playing with friends, you can count those random loot boxes to be split at least 50/50 if not by up to a quarter. Unless you’re *that* person who runs up to loot every box before anyone else can get to it.

I found myself without ammunition all too often while working my way through Borderlands 2‘s long quest lines. Enemies are tough; they require a lot of bullets shoved into their faces before they’ll go down. And they go down fighting. Robots will charge at you to explode with EMP power, which often took down my shields and dropped me close to death. Or they drag their half damaged bodies across the platform to you, even throwing grenades with their good arm. Survival is tough on Pandora since Handsome Jack took charge. His Hyperion-powered mechs and bounty-hunting bandits won’t make it easy for you.

I figured out that playing as the new siren, Maya, was not the best choice to power-solo through Borderlands 2. Granted, the new skill trees—separated into three main trees—are so varied from one another that my Maya may be completely different than another player’s Maya. I chose to be a more destructive Maya, dealing heavier damage and adding elemental effects to her strikes, but only after I tried her as more of a healing character. She still never felt too equipped to defend herself against the large waves of enemies Borderlands 2 constantly throws at you. Waves even mix with each other, sometimes to your detriment, but luckily sometimes to your benefit as you watch bandits kill off bullymongs.

But even when I played co-op, with fellow game journalists who chose the more independent commando or gunzerker, they found conserving ammunition to be just as much of an issue. It was next to impossible.

So I tried making the run all the way back to the start of the level to use all the cash I picked up on some direly needed ammunition. Some levels were so long, though, that enemies would start to respawn as I made my way back. It felt a little bit like torture. You could say it’s part of the challenge, that respawning enemies test your ability to complete missions under a timed pressure. If you feel that way, all the better. Because Borderlands 2 will have that pressure looming over your head. Take too long to finish off a wave of enemies, and they’ll be spawning behind you before you know it.

This kind of brutality on the player makes one thing crystal clear about Borderlands 2: it’s very much meant to be a co-op game. Especially when considering the siren, whose action ability is to suspend enemies in the air, it’s obvious that a lot of the game was made with the cooperative experience in mind.

The commando’s turrets make that class probably the most ideal for a solo experience, but power in numbers is heavily emphasized here. You’ll certainly be facing off against an overwhelming swarm of enemies at once, so you might as well come packing. The swarms sometimes feel endless. Having a friend or three at your back can mean the difference between getting through a quest in an hour or getting through the same quest in 20 minutes. Even with skill points spent towards increased critical hit percentage, deadeye aim and some wildass smartbomb talent, it’s still preferable to play with friends to get through it all.

Playing Borderlands 2 at its most ideal setting—namely, with friends—is still a challenge. Especially in later levels, you’ll often find yourself pressed up against a wall with so much chaos in front of you that your head will spin. And that’s a good thing, when you know you have friends to hold the fort while you run back from the last checkpoint.

Borderlands 2 is best played at the slowest pace possible. Explore. Try out all the mission board quests. Look around for yellow exclamation points as you drive through the map to pick up even more quests. Do each one. The variety in quests is refreshing, especially thinking back to side quests in Borderlands that often felt stale and monotonous. In Borderlands 2 side quests will take you to meet new quirky characters, learn more about Handsome Jack and his reign of terror, or learn more about the vault and Pandora and the original four vault hunters. There’s a lot to learn out there in your second pass through Pandora. There’s a lot of fun, funny new story arcs to experience, too.

The only downside to having a ton of fun side quests is that there’s no way to easily track them. There’s the standard method of organization that groups quests that are a part of the same area together on a list, but you can’t toggle through them easily on the map. You’ll have to manually cycle through them, clicking on new ones and then switching back to the map to see where you need to go. An indicator of a nearby quest on your way to your intended one seems like an easy addition. But really it’s just a minor nuisance. Just ask that one friend you always make drive to keep you on track with quests. I’m sure they’ll oblige (I always do, and I always like driving, too).

But there’s really only one thing that you need to know about Borderlands 2. It’s a tough, stylish, emotional ride through everything that made Borderlands 1 such a great game. Pick three friends, span the character classes, and get to killing. You won’t be disappointed.